Fed decision, December

Kalshi · PolymarketLiveNews effect 1.9×

87.0%25 bps increase

Leading outcome on Polymarket, live. All times UTC.

moved the price 7 didn’t 20? no news found 0

Loading prices…

Question 1 of 5

Does news move this market?

News moves this market 1.9× more often than chance (79 of 465 stories; random 9%)

Lift over random1.9×Intervals apart: a clear effect
Stories that moved the price17%79 of 465 · 95%: 14–21%
Random moments9%95%: 7–12%
Stories measured465Aug 19 – Nov 17

By source type

The bar is the share of that type’s stories that moved the price, its 95% interval lighter; the black tick is the random-moment rate (9%).

  • Newsroom19% 39 of 206
  • Wire14% 25 of 180
  • Unlisted accounts20% 11 of 55
  • Unlisted sites8% 1 of 13
  • Journalist29% 2 of 7
  • Official25% 1 of 4

Question 2 of 5

How does it react?

−14−70+7+14−1 hPost+15 min+1 h+4 h+24 h+72 h
All 79 stories that moved the price Unlisted accounts (11) Wire (25) Newsroom (39) Random moments, 95% band

Each story is signed by its own change at +1 hour, so the curve always rises to +1 h. Read what comes after: how much of the move is still there at +24 h and +72 h. Several stories inside one move share its peak.

Median time to peak2.7 hhalf within 1.1 h–4.8 h
Left after a day67%median share of the peak
Mostly reversed20%under a quarter left at +24 h
Price moved first16 of 792+ pts the same way in the hour before

Time to peak, one dot per story

0h6h12h18h24h

Share of the peak left after a day

0%50%100%150%

Question 3 of 5

Which sources move it?

Sources with five or more stories, by how often their stories moved the price. Under 15 stories the interval is too wide to rank on, so those rows are greyed.

SourceTypeStoriesMoved the price · tick: random 9%Median change
wsj.comWire4023% 9 of 405 pts
cnbc.comNewsroom13319% 25 of 1334 pts
@DeItaoneWire4319% 8 of 435.45 pts
@ReutersWire3010% 3 of 305 pts
reuters.comWire248% 2 of 244.5 pts
apnews.comWire186% 1 of 183.8 pts
bloomberg.comWire225% 1 of 229 pts
nbcnews.comNewsroom560% 3 of 52 pts
cnnespanol.cnn.comUnlisted site540% 2 of 55 pts
@NickTimiraosWire838% 3 of 84.5 pts
bbc.comNewsroom633% 2 of 64 pts
politico.comWire633% 2 of 63.75 pts

Question 4 of 5

Which moves had no news?

7 of 14 sharp moves had no credible post in the 30 minutes before them. For those on Polymarket, the money that went the move's way in that half hour, and who put it in.

WhenMoveEarly moneyWalletsTop walletLargest early traderAt peak
Nov 6, 13:30$82k3228%0xcf19c4…6402Profitable+$219k lifetime14%
Nov 5, 14:55———Not computed—
Oct 28, 17:45———Not computed—
Oct 2, 13:41———Not computed—
Sep 28, 12:55———Not computed—
Sep 28, 11:49———Not computed—
Sep 28, 09:27$78k698%0xe033e9…40a5Profitable specialist+$125k lifetime11%

Wallets that turn up early more than once

Wallets that put $200 or more into the early window of two or more unexplained moves, here or on other markets.

  • 0x2a3e6f…c051$2,500 early · 2 moves · 1 market

    • Nov 6$2,000
    • Nov 10$500

Question 5 of 5

Do the venues agree?

Kalshi repriced first2of 14 detected moves
Polymarket repriced first14 ties, 7 can't tell
Usual gap1.5 ptsmedian, 2 h before a move
Gap after a move5 ptsmedian peak, 2 h after

With 3 decided cases, the split is what a coin flip would give (sign test p = 1.00): no venue leads.

Resolution rules

  • Polymarket rounds an off-grid move up to the nearest 25 bps (a 12.5 bps hike counts as 25); Kalshi has no rounding rule.
  • If the meeting doesn't happen on Dec 9, Kalshi resolves “Fed maintains rate”; Polymarket waits for a statement until the end of the next scheduled meeting, then resolves “No change”. A postponed meeting that then moves rates pays differently.
  • Polymarket measures the change in the upper bound of the target range; Kalshi the FOMC's change to the range. Same unless only one bound moves.

News that moved it

Every event

Sort

Findings

  • Strong

    News moves this market more often than chance

    79 of 465 stories (17%, 95% interval 14%–21%) were followed by a price change bigger than 95% of this contract's changes at random moments, against 9% of random moments themselves.

  • Strong

    X posts don't beat newsroom coverage here

    Stories that include an X post moved the price 17% of the time (31 of 186); newsroom-only stories 17% (48 of 279); random moments 9%.

  • Strong

    Newsrooms lead the sources that move it

    Newsrooms 19% (39/206), unlisted sources 18% (12/68), wires 14% (25/180); random moments 9%.

  • Strong

    Moves after news mostly stick

    A day later, the median move kept 63% of its peak; 28% had mostly reversed (79 moves).

  • Strong

    The price sometimes moves before the story

    In 15 of 79 stories that moved the price, it had already moved 2+ points the same way in the hour before the first post or article.

  • Tentative

    Polymarket usually reprices first

    Where it could be told: Kalshi first 3, Polymarket first 8, within a minute 4. 23 of 79 moves opened a Kalshi−Polymarket gap 3+ points wider than usual.

  • Tentative

    Most big moves had no credible post first

    We searched X around the 14 largest moves. In 5 a relevant post from a listed account came in the 30 minutes before the price moved, a median 4 min ahead; in 9 nothing credible did. Most often first: @financialjuice (2), @federalreserve (1), @LiveSquawk (1).

  • Caveat

    Early money before unexplained moves came from established traders

    For 3 moves with no credible post first, we looked up the wallets that traded the move's way in the 30 min before (Polymarket wallet history from Nansen). In 1 a single wallet put in 80% or more of that money. The largest early trader had a profitable record in 3, and was a specialist in this topic in 1 (a wallet with at least 10 markets on it, net $125k). None of the early wallets was new: all had traded 12+ markets. No wallet is named; trading early is not proof of inside information.

  • Tentative

    Fed officials' own words are what move it

    The biggest repricings followed Fed officials speaking: Warsh at Jackson Hole on Aug 28 (No change −14.5 pts within 4 hours, 25 bp hike +12.5), Barkin on Nov 5 (No change +11) and Waller on Nov 10 (No change −11, reported by CNBC and the FT at 09:00 UTC). Data previews and commentary rarely cleared the bar.

    Warsh at Jackson Hole (Wall St Engine summary) ↗CNBC: Barkin sees hikes ahead ↗CNBC: Waller sees December hike likely ↗

  • Tentative

    Headline feeds carry the Fed speeches minute by minute

    On Jackson Hole day the Bloomberg headline account (DeItaone) posted Hammack's remarks at 13:34 UTC and the pre-speech setup at 13:49, before Warsh spoke; both stories cleared the bar. For Fed markets the wire squawks are the layer that times a break.

  • Caveat

    Venue gaps here are partly a rules difference

    Polymarket rounds an off-grid move up to the nearest 25 bp (a 12.5 bp hike counts as 25); Kalshi has no rounding rule. 23 of 79 moves opened a Kalshi−Polymarket gap 3+ points wider than usual, so not every gap is free money.

Method and limits

  • A story “moved the price” when the change within 1 or 4 hours was 2+ points and larger than 95% of the same contract’s changes at random moments. At a 9% random rate, about half of tagged stories could have qualified by chance: one tag is weak evidence, a market’s rate is not.
  • A story first seen from 30 minutes before a detected move to 10 minutes after it is merged into that move. Moving stories with no sharp move within 4 hours are shown as slow drifts.
  • “First post” means the earliest post found. X search returns a sample, and view counts are as of collection.
  • Wallets exist for Polymarket only; Kalshi accounts are private. Wallets that put $200+ into an early window are shown by public address. Trading early is not proof of inside information, and lifetime figures are not profit on the trade.
  • A venue gap is not arbitrage where the resolution rules differ. Here: Polymarket rounds an off-grid move up to the nearest 25 bps (a 12.5 bps hike counts as 25); Kalshi has no rounding rule.; If the meeting doesn't happen on Dec 9, Kalshi resolves “Fed maintains rate”; Polymarket waits for a statement until the end of the next scheduled meeting, then resolves “No change”. A postponed meeting that then moves rates pays differently.; Polymarket measures the change in the upper bound of the target range; Kalshi the FOMC's change to the range. Same unless only one bound moves..